3 Best Pizza Screens for 2023 Reviewed

By Robert Parsons March 28, 2023

Unlocking the key to Italian-style pizza lies in your tools – one of which is indispensable for a perfectly crisp crust: The pizza screen. Pizzerias have been utilizing them for years, and now you can too! Yet, not all screens are created equal; they vary in size, material, shape and cost. 

To ensure that you get quality equipment rather than an inferior product, it’s essential to be mindful of what features you need when shopping around.

If you’re looking to purchase a pizza screen but don’t know where to start, no need to worry! This buyer’s guide will provide detailed insight into what exactly is a pizza screen, how it works, and things you should consider before buying one. 

Plus – we’ll offer our top picks for the year so that your decision-making process doesn’t have any loose ends. Let’s get started on understanding all there is about this useful kitchen tool!

The Best Pizza Screens

Let us save you time and effort by presenting to you the three most remarkable pizza screens. Our team has taken it upon themselves to try, test, and evaluate each one individually so that all information is readily available when choosing which screen best suits your needs – we guarantee there’s something for everyone!

Product Review Rating Price
New Star Foodservice Pizza Screen Read Review 4.7
Winco Winware 16-Inch Pizza Screen Read Review 4.5
American Metalcraft Pizza Screen Read Review 4.4
Our Favourite

1. New Star Foodservice Pizza Screen

Looks / Appearance 5.0 / 5.0
Ease of use 4.5 / 5.0
Functionality 5.0 / 5.0


  • – Great for pizzerias and individuals alike
  • – Made of durable aluminum
  • – Wallet-friendly
  • – Improves air circulation for a crispier crust


  • – Not dishwasher safe

The Courant Pizza Maker offers delicious pizza in a matter of minutes. It’s packed with some impressive features despite its small, compact size.

2. Winco Winware 16-Inch Pizza Screen

Looks / Appearance 5.0 / 5.0
Ease of use 4.0 / 5.0
Functionality 4.0 / 5.0


  • – Affordably priced
  • – Delivers a crispy crust
  • – Made from durable material
  • – Fits up to a 16” pizza


  • – Does not fit all ovens
  • – Not very easy to wash

The Winco Winware is perfect for those who want the perfect balance between a crispy and chewy crust. It cooks a 16-inch pie evenly with a golden crust.

3. American Metalcraft Pizza Screen

Looks / Appearance 5.0 / 5.0
Ease of use 4.0 / 5.0
Functionality 4.0 / 5.0


  • – Great for making rectangular pizzas
  • – Easy to wash and store
  • – Cooks more than just pizza
  • – Great for commercial use


  • – Not dishwasher safe
  • – May not fit in oven (take measurements)

The American Metalcraft Rectangular Pizza Baking Screen is for anyone that enjoys making foods that go beyond pizza. The best part? The holes designed within the pan, give your food a greater circulation of air and heat retention.

Why Do You Need a Pizza Screen?

Soggy pizzas are a total bummer when it comes to watching movies or catching up with friends, but you can avoid such disappointment by using the right tools. Pizza screens crafted from aluminum provide superior heat transfer and exceptional ventilation for that perfect crunchy crust, making them ideal for both home and commercial ovens. Without those crucial holes allowing airflow to reach the pizza base, condensation would form leading to sodden pies – so don’t let this happen again!

Things to Consider When Buying a Pizza Screen

Before you purchase a pizza screen at your local grocery store, think twice! There are key elements to consider before making an informed buying decision. Here’s what you need to know:


To simplify your decision-making process, we strongly recommend that you opt for either aluminum or stainless-steel selections. Not only are these materials exceptionally durable and nonstick, but they will also last many years provided that you take proper care of them. For first-time users out there – don’t forget to season the screen before using it! This precautionary step is essential if you want to prevent your pie from sticking in the pan.

After use, we highly recommend cleaning your aluminum or stainless steel cookware by hand. While some models may be dishwasher safe, a thorough hand wash is the best way to ensure that all residue has been removed and you can keep it in top condition. Cleaning these materials doesn’t require much effort so taking an extra few minutes won’t hurt.


When it comes to pizza screens, you have the choice of three unique shapes – round, square, or rectangular. While rounded styles are usually most popular for creating traditional pies, non-circular options come in handy when baking larger dishes and cutting pieces into squares. Plus, using a square or rectangular screen is ideal for warming up breadsticks and pastries with ease.


When selecting a pizza screen, make sure it will fit in your oven. Don’t underestimate the size of the baking sheet–you don’t want to end up with an unusable product! Prioritize taking into account the measurements of your oven before deciding on a specific model. In this way, you’ll be assured that whatever you choose is compatible with your kitchen appliance and ready for use right away.


When it comes to pizza screens, the cost is generally quite reasonable. As you shop around and compare prices, keep in mind that a single screen can run from as little as $10 up to approximately $50 depending on its size and if it’s part of a set or not. To ensure optimal value for your money, make sure you are aware of how much you’re willing to invest in one before making any decisions!


If you want a restaurant-level pizza with the perfect crunch, invest in one of our top picks for quality pizza screens. Your pizzas are only as good as your cooking surface, so don’t settle for less than the best! With any of these options at your fingertips, you’re sure to achieve delicious pies every time. Enjoy making and eating them all.