3 Best Pizza Screens for 2021 Reviewed

By Robert Parsons May 28, 2021

The secret to making authentic Italian-style pizza is in the tools you use. For instance – a pizza screen. This is an essential tool needed to create a perfectly crisp crust! Pizzerias use them on a regular basis, and now you can too.

However, not all pizza screens are made the same. They differ in size, material, shape, and price. To avoid purchasing a subpar product, you need to know what to look for.

However, not all pizza screens are made the same. They differ in size, material, shape, and price. To avoid purchasing a subpar product, you need to know what to look for.

In this buyer’s guide, we will go over what a pizza screen is, how it works, things to consider before buying one, and much more! We’ll leave no question unanswered and even bring you our top pizza screen picks for 2021.

Let’s get started!

The Best Pizza Screens

We’ve done the busy work and bring you the best options in 2021. Take a look at the top 3 pizza screens currently on the market. Our team has tried, tested, and reviewed them to bring you all the details. We know one of them will fit the bill.

Product Review Rating Price
New Star Foodservice Pizza Screen Read Review 4.7 Check Price
Winco Winware 16-Inch Pizza Screen Read Review 4.5 Check Price
American Metalcraft Pizza Screen Read Review 4.4 Check Price
Our Favourite

1. New Star Foodservice Pizza Screen

4.7/5.0
Looks / Appearance 5.0 / 5.0
Ease of use 4.5 / 5.0
Functionality 5.0 / 5.0

Pros

  • – Great for pizzerias and individuals alike
  • – Made of durable aluminum
  • – Wallet-friendly
  • – Improves air circulation for a crispier crust

Cons

  • – Not dishwasher safe

The Courant Pizza Maker offers delicious pizza in a matter of minutes. It’s packed with some impressive features despite its small, compact size.

2. Winco Winware 16-Inch Pizza Screen

4.5/5.0
Looks / Appearance 5.0 / 5.0
Ease of use 4.0 / 5.0
Functionality 4.0 / 5.0

Pros

  • – Affordably priced
  • – Delivers a crispy crust
  • – Made from durable material
  • – Fits up to a 16” pizza

Cons

  • – Does not fit all ovens
  • – Not very easy to wash

The Winco Winware is perfect for those who want the perfect balance between a crispy and chewy crust. It cooks a 16-inch pie evenly with a golden crust.

3. American Metalcraft Pizza Screen

4.4/5.0
Looks / Appearance 5.0 / 5.0
Ease of use 4.0 / 5.0
Functionality 4.0 / 5.0

Pros

  • – Great for making rectangular pizzas
  • – Easy to wash and store
  • – Cooks more than just pizza
  • – Great for commercial use

Cons

  • – Not dishwasher safe
  • – May not fit in oven (take measurements)

The American Metalcraft Rectangular Pizza Baking Screen is for anyone that enjoys making foods that go beyond pizza. The best part? The holes designed within the pan, give your food a greater circulation of air and heat retention.

Why Do You Need a Pizza Screen?

Undercooked, soggy pizzas are the worst snack to eat while watching a movie or hanging with friends. To avoid this from happening, you need a pizza screen.

Many screens are made from aluminum. This material transfers heat very well, and because of the mesh design, airflow reaches the crust. They can be used in a home oven or commercial oven. The ventilation provided is what gives pies that crispy crust. Without the holes, condensation would build up leading to soggy pizzas.

Things to Consider When Buying a Pizza Screen

Don’t go with the first pizza screen you find at your local grocery store. There are some things you need to factor into your buying decision to make a smart purchase. Consider the following:

Material

We are going to make this easy on you – always go with an aluminum or stainless-steel selection. These are durable and non-stick materials. They will last you several years as long as you care for them properly. If it’s your first time using the screen, season it to prep it. Not seasoning it may cause the pie to stick. 

After you’re done using it, hand wash it. Some models may be dishwasher safe, but we always recommend washing by hand. Aluminum and stainless steel is fairly easy to clean and won’t be much of a hassle to wash by hand.

Shape

Pizza screens come in three shapes: round, square, and rectangular. The one you go with depends on your personal preferences. Most pizza screens are rounded, but you can also buy in a square shape or rectangular one. These are great if you want to bake larger pies or cut pieces into squares. Non-circular ones are also great when warming up breadsticks or pastries.

Size

You want to make sure you invest in a pizza screen that will fit in your oven. Too often, users underestimate the size of their baking screen only to find it does not fit in their oven. If it happens to be bigger than your oven, you’ll never use it! Therefore, always factor in the dimensions of your oven before settling on a pizza screen. 

Price

Pizza screens come at a pretty low price; however, it’s always a good idea to know what you’re willing to spend on one. You’ll see that some screens come as low as $10 or as high as $50. The price depends on the size of the screen and whether you’re purchasing a set or a single piece. 

Conclusion

Your pizza is only going to taste as good as the surface you bake it on. Invest in a quality pizza screen and enjoy a delicious pie with a crispy crust. We are sure any of our picks above will be suitable for your kitchen and bring you restaurant-grade pies. Happy baking!